|Please sign (click here) our petition: Mayor de Blasio: Rescue Our Libraries from Developer Destruction|
Please contribute (we are now fundraising to litigate):
|Please sign click here to contribute on our Gofundme campaign|
Mayor Bloomberg defunded New York libraries at a time of increasing public use, population growth and increased city wealth, shrinking our library system to create real estate deals for wealthy real estate developers at a time of cutbacks in education and escalating disparities in opportunity. It’s an unjust and shortsighted plan that will ultimately hurt New York City’s economy and competitiveness.
It should NOT be adopted by those we have now elected to pursue better policies.
|Please sign (click here) our petition: Mayor de Blasio: Rescue Our Libraries from Developer Destruction|
|Please sign click here to contribute on our Gofundme campaign|
Defend our libraries, don't defund them. . . . . fund 'em, don't plunder 'ema number of significant successes fending off and preventing library sale and shrinkages and there has been some progress towards restoration of the funding of libraries to a proper pre-library-sales plan level of proper funding, but the libraries are still besieged by the threat of such plans.
|Chart from Center From an Urban Future report showing sharp decline in funding (coinciding with plans to sell off/"leverage" libraries) against escalating use.|
|This José Marti quote which can be found in this plaque on 41st Street's Library Walk is included in the petition to save New York City's libraries|
• New York Times: Critic’s Notebook- In Renderings for a Library Landmark, Stacks of Questions, by Michael Kimmelman, January 29, 2013.“There is no more important landmark building in New York than the New York Public Library, known to New Yorkers simply as the 42nd Street Library, one of the world's greatest research institutions. Completed in 1911 . . . . it is an architectural masterpiece. Yet it is about to undertake its own destruction. The library is on a fast track to demolish the seven floors of stacks just below the magnificent, two-block-long Rose Reading Room for a $300 million restructuring referred to as the Central Library Plan.”
• Noticing New York:“this potential Alamo of engineering, architecture and finance would be irresponsible. . . a not-uncommon phenomenon among cultural boards, a form of architectural Stockholm syndrome.”
• New City-Wide Policy Makes Generation Of Real Estate Deals The Library System’s Primary Purpose, (January 31, 2013).
“Do we want a shrinking library system for a growing, wealthier city? . .
. . . It’s what we are going to get as the principal purpose of the library system becomes the generation of real estate opportunities for developers. This new city-wide policy has, in a very harmful way, turned into a perverse incentive for the city to defund libraries and drive them into the ground.”
• City Strategy Of Withholding Basic City Services To Blackmail Public Into Accepting Bigger Development, (Friday, February 1, 2013)
• What Could We Expect Forest City Ratner Would Do With Two Library Sites On Sale For The Sake Of Creating Real Estate Deals? (Sunday, February 3, 2013)
Two of the sites identified for sale in the forefront of this march towards divestiture of assets with a concomitant shrinkage of the system are in Brooklyn. . . . Whether by coincidence or not, both of these sites . . are immediately adjacent to property the government has previously put in the hands of Forest City Ratner pursuant to no-bid deals . . .• Libraries That Are Now Supposedly “Dilapidated” Were Just Renovated: And Are Developers’ Real Estate Deals More Important Than Bryant Park? (Saturday, February 9, 2013)
• If Our Besieged Libraries Could Speak For Themselves: Maybe They Do! A Petition And Efforts To Save New York’s Libraries From Developer Deals, (Wednesday, February 20, 2013)• Center For An Urban Future: Report - Branches of Opportunity, by David Giles, January 2013
The greatest shame of such a plan is that it, even if it shakes loose a few real estate deals, maybe a few every year, it is a travesty to continually drives all libraries and the entire system into the ground financially.
• New York City Independent Budget Office: Funding Cuts Could Shelve Many Library Branches, by Kate Maher and Doug Turetsky, April 13, 2011[Libraries] “have experienced a 40 percent spike in the number of people attending programs and a 59 percent increase in circulation over the past decade”
.• The Albert Shanker Institute: The High Cost Of Closing Public Libraries, by Matthew Di Carlo, April 18, 2011“The funding fall-off is already taking a toll on the city’s three library systems, particularly the systems in Brooklyn and Queens.” . . .“more than three dozen branch libraries may be closed.” [Bloomberg on a course to bring waning city funding for New York’s three library systems to its] “lowest level since the 1990s.” [The city’s 59 community boards ranked library services their] “third highest budget concern” . . [and] “Brooklyn’s community boards ranked libraries their top priority.”
• The Daily News: Coming to Brooklyn Heights: the incredible shrinking library, patrons and residents charge -- Controversial plan to sell library building to private developer who will build apartment tower over it, by Lore Croghan, February 17, 2013.In fiscal year 2008 (again, according to the U.S. Census Bureau), there were roughly 9,300 public libraries in the U.S., with a total cost of around 10.7 billion dollars. That figure represents roughly 0.4 percent – four tenths of one percent – of all state and local government expenditures. On a per capita basis, this is about 35 dollars per person. [local-level analyses] “have found that for every dollar we spent on public libraries, the public realizes about 3-5 dollars in benefits.”
. . . a controversial plan to sell the city-owned Brooklyn Heights Library building to a private developer who will erect an apartment tower with a new, 15,000 square foot branch - smaller than the book hall that’s there now.. . . many patrons use the business library like it’s part of their neighborhood branch — and are upset the space will be eliminated.• Library Journal: Donnell sale highlights need for transparency in decision-making, by Francine Fialkoff, Editor-in-Chief, February 1, 2008.
. . . the building that housed Donnell has been sold to make way for a hotel and a much smaller public library. . (w)ith the proposed library having less than half the space for public services as the old Donnell . . . questions remain about the location of some of the collections. . . More importantly, the breakup of the collections diminishes the role of Donnell as a central library . . . The decisions . . . [were] communicated to staff (and in the case of Donnell, to the public) largely after the big decisions have been made.• Walkers In The City: Patience and Fortitude, by Romy Ashby. February 22, 2013.
Should a public/private entity like NYPL. . so blithely sidestep public and staff input? [The] Libraries Subcommittee chair of the New York City Council . . . “. . didn't know about the Donnell sale ahead of time.” “It's troubling . . . in terms of . . the whole mission of the library.”
. . . It's way past time for NYPL leaders to come out from behind their cloak of secrecy. . get staff and public feedback before making any other sweeping changes.
The meeting was crowded with mostly older people hearing the same kind of talk about their library and smelling a rat. “The 42nd Street library isn’t the only library in trouble,” a man said. “It’s the whole library system.” A lady in her seventies told of standing up to Robert Moses and winning. “We’re not gonna watch our libraries be demolished!” she said. “We want the library we have, nothing less! The minute you give in to their conditions you’re finished! You get bupkis!” I sat and listened, and some of what I heard was this:• The Leonard Lopate Show: Controversy at the New York Public Library, Scott Sherman, a contributing writer for The Nation and Caleb Crain, a former Fellow at the NYPL and author of American Sympathy, talk about the proposed changes, staffing cuts and construction plans, March 12, 2012.
The city is deliberately underfunding the libraries despite library use being way up. Perfectly good libraries are being labeled ‘Dilapidated’ to justify their destruction. Librarians have been warned to sound enthusiastic if asked about any such plans. The money from the sale of libraries will not go back into the library system, despite what library brass may say. . .
For two years, the NYPL has refused to discuss the CLP in detail, and many questions remain unanswered. How and why did one of the world’s greatest libraries get into the real estate business? How did the CLP, which was formulated between 2005 and early 2007, advance into late 2011 without any significant public debate or discussion? Who first conceived the idea of demolishing book stacks that were constructed by Carrère and Hastings in the first decade of the twentieth century? What role did the Bloomberg administration play in the creation of the CLP? Finally, what was the role of Booz Allen Hamilton—the gargantuan consulting firm whose tentacles reach into the defense, energy, transportation and financial service sectors—which was hired by the NYPL in 2007 to formulate what became known inside the trustee meetings as “the strategy”?• The Wall Street Journal: Clueless at the Corcoran- What the museum's latest bad decision says about nonprofit governance, by Eric Gibson, February, 24, 2014.
. . . the untold story of our time is the emerging crisis in nonprofit governance, where boards embark on policies that go against-and even imperil-the mission of the institution they are charged to oversee and protect.• The Brooklyn Eagle (Exclusive): Brooklyn Public Library in line for audit, says Comptroller Stringer, by Mary Frost, February, 28, 2014.
. . . The New York Public Library wants to gut its magnificent Beaux Arts building on Fifth Avenue and change it from a research institution to, as Ada Louise Huxtable wrote in this newspaper, "a state-of-the-art, socially interactive, computer-centered" circulating library, with fewer books, a good number of them moved off-site.
Groups opposing the controversial sales of Brooklyn and Manhattan library branches to developers have long been pushing for an audit of the BPL and NPL systems. . .• City Limits: New Scrutiny of City's Library Trustees- The trustees of the city's library systems oversee more than 200 branches and the spending of hundreds of millions of city dollars. How representative of the city are they?, by Suzanne Travers, June 18, 2014.
“Some of the things raised with respect to the Queens library system are interesting and worth investigating but the Queens expenditures ($140K for a conference deck) are penny ante compared to the library sales at the NPL and the BPL,” commented Michael D. D. White, a founding member of Citizens Defending Library, following a Brian Lehrer interview with Comptroller Stringer. “The Queens Library system has not been selling off libraries like the other two,” White added.
Over the last year, library trustees have seen more of the spotlight than usual because of moves that put boards at odds with public opinion. . .• The Brian Lehrer Show: Giving Libraries Their Due, David Giles, research director at the Center for an Urban Future and the author of the report, "Branches of Opportunity", argues that New York City's public libraries deserve even more support in the digital age. (Click below to listen) January 15, 2013.
* * *
As repositories of information available to anyone who walks through the door, libraries have always helped foster transparency, accountability and democracy. Their boards, however, struggle on all three counts.
More people visited public libraries in New York than every major sports team and every major cultural institution combined.
|Chart from the Independent Budget Office- Adjustments for inflation (per the Urban Future report) shows downturn in starkest relief.|
|Meville House article on Citizens Defending Libraries event used picture from July rally where Bill de Blasio joined CDL to call for a halt to these library sales. Video of event on CDL's Youtube channel.|
Citizens Defending Libraries, which was co-founded by Michael D. D. White and Carolyn McIntyre, has been organizing protests and actions against the Central Library Plan. They have told us that they are continuing to solicit "petition signatures to ensure the de Blasio administration scraps all of the Bloomberg library sell-off plans.". .• New York Times: Denying New York Libraries the Fuel They Need, by Jim Dwyer, April 23, 2015.
. . . Citizens Defending Libraries is just now arriving at our first anniversary, just blowing out the single candle on our birthday cake. We formed in response to breaking headlines at the very beginning of last year about how libraries were being sold off at the end of the Bloomberg administration in deals that would benefit real estate developers, not the public.
The city's libraries - the fusty old buildings, and a few spiffier modern ones, . . have more users than major professional sports, performing arts, museums, gardens and zoos - combined.
* * * *
Over the last decade, they have not gotten anywhere near the kind of capital funding enjoyed by sports teams.
From the 2006 fiscal year through 2014, the city budgeted at least $464 million to build new baseball stadiums for the Yankees and the Mets, and $156 million for the Barclays Center. That's $620 million for just those three sports arenas - a sum more than one-third greater than the $453 million that the city committed for capital improvements to the its 206 branch libraries and four research centers, which serve roughly seven times as many people a year as attend baseball games. (The budget figures were provided by the city's Independent Budget Office; the teams are getting an additional $680 million in subsidies spread over 40 years.)
For decades, the libraries have served a single function in the city budget process: hostages. Mayors say they have to cut library hours to make the financial books balance.. .Additional Links. For more in a running series of Noticing New York articles about the libraries click here: Libraries Series. Also, here are pages with articles that reference respectively 1.) The Central Library Plan affecting the Tilden Astor Central Reference Library at 42nd Street, the Mid-Manhattan, Library, SIBL and the Donnell, 2.) The Brooklyn Heights libraries, and The Pacific Branch library, and 3.) Libraries in general.
|Foreground: The lion Patience , of Patience and Fortitude fame, in front of 42nd Street Research Library, whose research stacks will be sacrificed. Background: Mid-Manhattan Library that will be sold in system shrinkage plans|
Governor Andrew Cuomo and NYS Health Department Commissioner Dr. Nirav Shah : Keep University Hospital Brooklyn at Long Island College Hospital open, by Assemblywoman Joan Millman
|The morning crowd waiting for the Brooklyn Heights downtown library to open|
• Please refer to the calendar above for upcoming events. We have switched over to this (together with periodic emails to signers of the petition) as the primary means of updating people although we may occasionally list put certain future events down below here to get them extra attention.
• Important Note Respecting One Of The Events In The Calendar Above- The Jun 8 – 9, 2013 24-Hour Library Read-In by New Yorkers Standing Up for Libraries- Hosted by Urban Librarians Unite. This is one of the events on the calendar not organized by Citizens Defending Libraries (most are not). Urban Librarians Unite (created circa 2008) contacted Citizens Defending Libraries to express their wish that Citizens Defending Libraries communicate Urban Liberians Unite's wish that people not come to attend their 24-Hour Library Read-In event if they believe:
• We shouldn’t be selling off our NYC libraries the way we are.Urban Librarians Unite also informed CDL that they considered inclusion of this publicly advertised (previously come-one-come-all event) public event in the calender “unacceptable.” In other words they wanted to Shush us about their "We Will Not Be Shushed Read In June 8 & 9th! Sign Up Now!" event. Urban Librarians Unite objected to the testimony CCL delivered at the City Council budget hearing on June 5, 2013 and apparently, there was concern on their part that people with negative feelings about library sales and shrinkage might participate in the event to express their opposition to underfunding of libraries, or that such people might communicate with attendees of the event about this related subject. CDL doe not allow those holding public events to dictate exclusion (or inclusions) of information in the calendar about relevant library related events (mayoral forums, library trustee events, etc.), but agreed, in this instance to express the above about ULU's conscientious efforts to exclude public opposition to the library sales and shrinkage from their message.
• We shouldn’t be shrinking our library system assets
• It is a matter of public concern that we are getting less than appropriate value when these assets are sold, and/or
• Public representatives should assert themselves to protect these public assets.
Recent and past Events
• Sunday, February 17th, 5:00 PM: Progressive Community Building Event, Brooklyn Heights, Montague & Hicks Streets
• Sunday, February 24th, 4:00 PM: Progressive Community Building Event, Brooklyn Heights (Clark & Monroe)
• Thursday, February 28, 5:00 PM: People should show up early for a meeting at the Brooklyn Heights Library (280 Cadman Plaza) about the proposed sell-off and shrinkage of that library, possibly to Forest City Ratner. It will include attendance by elected representatives, City Councilman Steve Levin and State Senator Daniel Squadron and representatives of the Brooklyn Heights Association.
• Sunday, March 3, 4:00 PM: Progressive Community Building Event, Brooklyn Heights (Clark & Monroe) Petition signers are invited to click on the link to sign up for this event (on Moveon.org) where next steps in our campaign will be discussed.
sign-up LINK to let us know us know you are coming - Council green sheet notice in image at right, click to enlarge) There will be a City Council hearing about the city budget for libraries meaning that it will provide a forum for addressing the defunding of libraries and the “demolition by neglect” of the library system preparatory to its shrinkage through the proposed sell-offs to developers. We are planning a demonstration for 10:30 AM when we expect press to be there. The public will have to wait to testify last, starting at 1:00 PM. Citizens Defending Libraries has issued a press release. Pictures and testimony are available here: Testimony By Citizens Defending Libraries At March 8, 2013 City Council Committee Hearing On Library Budget Issues
• Saturday, March 9, 4:30 PM: Progressive Community Building Event, Brooklyn Heights (Clark & Monroe) Petition signers are invited to click on the link to sign up for this event (on Moveon.org) where next steps in our campaign will be discussed.
• Tuesday, March 12, 2013, 5:30 PM: The City Services and Budget Committee of Community Board 5 will meet 5:30 p.m. at the Board Office, 450 Seventh Ave, Suite 2109, to discuss and respond to the Mayor's Preliminary budget. The Community Board should be asked to oppose the Central Library Plan and the shrinkage of the City’s libraries, particularly the main libraries within their district for the sake of all New Yorkers in the city, to oppose the defunding of libraries being used as an excuse for these real estate deals and should be asked to stand up and demand that Donnell Library (also being consolidated in the shrinkage of the CLP) be restored to it original size or bigger, rather than being shrunk to ½ or 1/3 of its previous size.
• Wednesday, March 13, 10:00 AM: Join the District Council 37 Local 1930 New York Public Library Guild Rally on the steps of City Hall for an immediate change to a permanent baseline funding for New York City's libraries.
• Saturday, March 16, 2:00 - 4:00 PM: Canvassing outside Brooklyn Heights Branch and Business and Career Library (weather reasonably permitting).
• Sunday, March 17, 4:00 PM: Progressive Community Building Event, Brooklyn Heights (Clark & Monroe) Petition signers are invited to click on the link to sign up for this event (on Moveon.org) where next steps in our campaign will be discussed.
• Tuesday, March 19, 2013, 6:30 PM: Meeting of trustees of the "Friends of the Brooklyn Heights Library" (not really friends) at Brooklyn Heights Library (280 Cadman Plaza). Public not invited.
• Wednesday, March 20, 2013, 10:00 AM: City Planning Commission review and public hearing for the Walentas Two Tree Development BAM South project in connection with which BPL is proposing the closing and sell-off of the Pacific Branch library. 22 Reade Street.
• Wednesday, March 20, 2013, 6:30 PM: Committee of Brooklyn's Community Board 6 meeting for the BPL's first presentation of its intentions to representatives of the community board (after the City Planning hearing) with respect to its proposed closing and sell-off of the Pacific Branch library and the proposed opening of a library in in the Walentas Two Tree Development BAM South project. 78th Police Precinct, 65 6th Avenue, Court Room (between Bergen/Dean Streets).
• Thursday, March 21, 5:00 PM: Meeting (open to the public) chaired by "Friends of the Brooklyn Heights Library" (not really friends) on behalf of Brooklyn Public Library at the request of Brooklyn Heights Association to further the sale and shrinkage of the Brooklyn Heights library. Elected's and their representatives may attend to participate. At Brooklyn Heights Library (280 Cadman Plaza).
• Saturday, March 23, 2:00 - 4:00 PM: Canvassing outside Brooklyn Heights Branch and Business and Career Library (weather reasonably permitting).
• Sunday, March 24, 4:00 PM: Progressive Community Building Event, Brooklyn Heights (Clark & Monroe) Petition signers are invited to click on the link to sign up for this event (on Moveon.org) where next steps in our campaign will be discussed.
• Saturday, March 30, 2:00 - 4:00 PM: Canvassing outside Brooklyn Heights Branch and Business and Career Library (weather reasonably permitting).
• Wednesday, April 3, 6:00 PM: Mayoral Forum. St. Francis College, 180 Remsen Street, Brooklyn New York 11201.
• Sunday, April 7, 4:00 PM: (We are skipped a week because of Easter) Progressive Community Building Event, Brooklyn Heights (Clark & Clinton) Petition signers are invited to click on the link to sign up for this event (on Moveon.org) where next steps in our campaign will be discussed.
• Thursday, April 11, 8:00 PM: Mayoral Forum. Jewish Center of Jackson Heights. See calendar above.
• Citizens Defending Libraries Libary Protection Week Events- A Series of Events from Saturday, April 13th to Thursday April 18th: [This week of events is documented in pictures, video and vido links here: PHOTO GALLERY- CDL's Library Protection Week and there is also a press release for the culminating City Hall CDL Press Conference with Comptroller John C. Liu.] Come to our rallies to protect and defend our public Libraries from being underfunded and sold off to private developers. Let our public officials know they need to put a halt to any more sales and restore proper funding to the system! See events below culminating at City Hall with the New York City Comptroller.NYS Assemblywoman Joan MillmanCity Council Member Stephen Levin speakingBrooklyn Heights Library280 Cadman Plaza by Tillary• Pacific LibraryPark Slope/Boerum Hill BrooklynFor more info (and you can let us know you are coming)
• (Sunday, April 14, 4:00 PM: Also listed below- Citizens Defending Libraries regular weekly planning meeting, - not officially part of Library Protection Week events- Progressive Community Building Event, Brooklyn Heights (Clark & Clinton) NOTE: Comptroller John Liu will visit and speak with use from 4:00 PM to 4:30 PM.)
• Monday, April 15, Noon to 1:00
In front of 42st Central Reference Library and Mid-Manhattan BranchFor more info (and you can let us know you are coming)20 West 53rd Street, between 5th and 6th Avenues, (meet on 40 West 53rd)Home of Winnie The Pooh, rare music CDs, and documentariesSold off to a developer in 2008 and still no promised replacementCome say We Remember and Never Again!For more info (and you can let us know you are coming)Steps of City HallComptroller John Liu to speakCome early to go through securitySign up, get info here (and you can let us know you are coming)
• Sunday, April 14, 4:00 PM: Progressive Community Building Event, Brooklyn Heights (Clark & Clinton) NOTE: Comptroller John Liu will visit and speak with use from 4:00 PM to 4:30 PM. Petition signers are invited to click on the link to sign up for this event (on Moveon.org) where next steps in our campaign will be discussed.
• Saturday, April 20, 9:30 AM (doors open): Mayoral Forum on Public Housing at Salvation Army Auditorium (starts at 10:30 AM) . See calendar above.
• Sunday, April 21, 4:00 PM: Progressive Community Building Event, Brooklyn Heights (Clark & Clinton) Petition signers are invited to click on the link to sign up for this event (on Moveon.org) where next steps in our campaign will be discussed.
• Monday, April 22, 6:00 PM: Mayoral Forum on Sustainability. See calendar above.
• Tuesday, April 23, 8:30 AM: Mayoral Forum on Small Business and Workforce issues. See calendar above.
• Wednesday, April 24, 6:00 PM: Community Board 2 Cultural Committee meeting, presentation from BPL on sale and shrinkage of Brooklyn Heights Library, also report on Clinton Hill and Walt Whitman libraries. See calendar above.
• Sunday, April 28, 4:00 PM: Progressive Community Building Event, Community Room in 101 Clark Street, Brooklyn Heights (Clark & Clinton) where next steps in our campaign will be discussed.
• Create Your Own Event!!!: It might be canvassing outside your own library or library of your choice. Or maybe an information event at your school or church. Contact us if you would like our help or suggestions. We can post information about your event here. We will also be happy to coordinate to send a representative to your event.CONTACT: To contact Citizens Defending Libraries email Backpack362 (at) aol.com.
(We invite you to contact Citizens Defending Libraries with more information about what is going on with libraries you know about to add more information to this list. See contact information and comments sections at bottom of page.)• Libraries everywhere in New York City? At a November 18, 2015 City Council hearing Brooklyn Public Library President Linda Johnson said that the sale and shrinkage of the Brooklyn Heights Library (itself modeled after the sale and shrinkage of the NYPL's Donnell library) was being looked at by all three NYC library systems (Brooklyn, the NYPL and Queens) as a model for similar transactions.
• The Donnell Library (53rd between 5th and 6th Avenues) was closed for shrinkage in 2008, its collection disbursed. Its former location now a construction site, “plans” having not worked out. Perhaps a half-size library will be provided by 2014.
• The main research library at 42nd Street will have its recently-renovated research stacks destroyed, decommissioning it as the premier world class research resource it was meant to be.
• Mid-Manhattan (Across Fifth Avenue) will be sold as part of the consolidating shrinkage plan.
• The relatively new Science Library at 34th Street will also be sold as part of the consolidating shrinkage plan.
• Further down the list are. . . ?
• When the NYPL unveiled its system-wide real estate plans to staff in March of 2008 it identified a plan to put a new hub library in Northern Manhattan (Harlem?). This is the only new hub library that seems to have been proposed anywhere. What this plans means cannot be said with certainty, but going back to the Donnell Library closing in 2008, following through with consolidating shrinkage of the proposed Central Library Plan and now the sell-off of the Brooklyn Heights library, all central or hub libraries of any kind have been associated with the sale and shrinkage of other previously existing libraries in the vicinity. Therefore, there shoud be concern about the upcoming sale and closing of libraries in northern Manhattan and Harlem.• Spaceworks and its mission to shrink and privatize NYC public library space as "underutilized" a threat to NYPL (Manhattan , Bronx and Staten Island) and BPL (Brooklyn) and possible Queens Libraries:
Recent news has come out that the private company Spaceworks, created by the Bloomberg administration in the summer of 2012 is decalred to be partnering with the NYPL and BPL with the mission of taking over and privatizing space in NYPL and BPL libraries based on the premise that the space in the libraries, despite greatly increasing use, is "underutilized." See: Thursday, July 3, 2014, Spaceworks And Its Privatizing Space Grab Of The Libraries. The two of libraries first announced as guinea pigs for Spaceworks shrinkage are the recentlt renovated Red Hook and Williamsburg libraries. Spaceworks mission is promoted by the Revson Foundation. The Revson Foundation funded a recent study by the Center for and Urban Future that concluded that libraries that are only 10,000 square feet should be enlarged. Notwithstanding, the Red Hook Library is only 7,500 square feet and Spacework was proposing with the BPL to shrink that library by 2,000 square feet down to to only 5,500 square feet.• Libraries in Brooklyn:
Spaceworks has been asked to identify what other libraries is it working on plans to shrink in its partnerships with the BPL and NYPL. Spaceworks has denied, despite its proclaimed partnership with the NYPL, that it has any plans underway to shrink any NYPL libraries in Manhattan, the Bronx or Staten Island and denies that it has any other Brooklyn libraries in its sites to shrink. It is not clear whether, with the board changes now underway at the Queens library whether Spaceworks will try to operate in Queens as well.
The Brooklyn Public Library has a strategic plan that is looking to "leverage" (turn into real estate deals) ALL of the libraries in the system. The most up-to-date information about libraries being targeted and in the most imminent possible danger comes from a recent thorough review of a decades worth of the BPL's board minutes. See: Sunday, August 31, 2014, Mostly In Plain Sight (A Few Conscious Removals Notwithstanding) Minutes Of Brooklyn Public Library Tell Shocking Details Of Strategies To Sell Brooklyn's Public Libraries. Based on that review, Citizens Defending Libraries has launched its Citizens Audit and Investigation which includes using the state sunshine laws to obtain more information about all of the following libraries talked about as being part of the BPL real estate strategy:
• Brooklyn Heights LibraryHere is more information:
• Pacific Branch
• Sunset Park Branch
• Red Hook Branch
• Williamsburg Branch
• Brower Park Library
• Midwood Library
• Gravesend Library
• Clinton Hill Library
• McKinley Park Branch and another seven or eight leased libraries being acquired with or without the formal threat of eminent domain.
• The Brooklyn Branch library at 280 Cadman Plaza will be closed and shrunk to become a much smaller library in what has been spoken of (internally by library officials) as likely being a forty-story building likely owned, library officials say, in a “Partnership” with Forest City Ratner. Library officials have indicated they can justify keeping the smaller library open shorter hours. The current library space, which also hosts the Business and Career library, is 62,000 square feet. This would be reduced to and orriginall proposed 16,000 square feet (now 21,000 square feet). Library officials are arguing that the space used by the public would effectively be cut only in half.
• The Business and Career library would be booted out of its current and traditional location at the edge of Brooklyn’s Central Business District (at a transportation hub and adjacent to universities). (This would help the library to keep shorter hours in Brooklyn Heights) To the extent that Business and Career library continued to exist at all afterwards it would be by virtue of jamming it into (and effectively shrinking) the Main Branch Library in Prospect Heights at Grand Army Plaza.
• The Main Brooklyn Library at Grand Army Plaza will be shrunk to the extent that other libraries elsewhere are closed and shrunk and shunted off services get jammed into this library.
• The Pacific branch library, (recently renovated), the first Carnegie Building opened in Brooklyn and a proposed landmark that the City Landmark’s commissioner has refused to act on since 2004, would be closed.
• There is information coming together from several sources that the Clinton Hill Library, 380 Washington Avenue (at Lafayette Ave, two blocks from Clinton), Brooklyn, NY 11238 is being looked at for sale to a developer. It is one of the libraries that has been the subject of recent sporadic closures claiming air conditioning or (March 2013) lack of heat.
• The Midwood Library was one of the first libraries that a developer made an offer on. The BPL said it is looking at all possibilities.
• The Sunset Park Branch was specifically identified as being a library that would be solf to be turned into a mixed-use property.
• The BPL received a developer proposal for the Brower Park Library and asked that it be made more specific.
• There is a list of other Brooklyn libraries on the list for development. Although the Brooklyn Public Library system denies it, libraries on the list were handed out to developers at least as far back as 2007. (People visiting the Brooklyn Heights library building are being told that the Brooklyn Heights library is the only library affected by the current sell-off and shrinkage plans, information that is obviously incorrect.)
• The strategic plan for the Brooklyn Public Library states that the plan is to “leverage” (i.e. “sell”) all of the real estate. The BPL: “will leverage its over one million square feet of real estate by launching partnerships . . .”
• The (Rupert Murdoch-owned) Brooklyn Paper that promotes the interests of the real estate developers ran two articles March 27, 2013. One was run in lieu of covering of covering a Community Board 5 hearing where the community was out in force strenuously objecting as BPL spokespeople presented their plans to sell the Pacific Branch library. That article, labeled a "News Analysis" in the print edition of the paper, was comprised of quotes and talking points of the BPL spokesman stating why the library should be sold and why Andrew Carnegie who donated this and other libraries on the condition that they be kept open and maintained would want to see such libraries sold off. Along with that article the paper ran another article where, according to Curbed, a real estate blog, the “Brooklyn Paper helpfully outlined every at-risk Carnegie branch in the borough.” Accordingly, that article gives clues to other libraies likely to be put on the block for sale. Another clue to which libraries are likely to be sold are which libraries get reported to have air conditioning problems. So far no library (going back to Donnell in 2008) has been proposed for sale without citing air conditioning problems, whether that library was recently renovated or not. A list of libraries with air conditioning problems appeared in the Brooklyn Eagle at the end of the Summer 2012. Libraries overlapping on these two lists as being in poor condition and having air conditioning problems, in addition to the Brooklyn Heights library and the Pacific Branch Library include also the Clinton Hill Library, 380 Washington Avenue and the Brownsville branch, 61 Glenmore Ave. at Watkins St. Brooklyn, NY 11212. Other still open Carnegie libraries Brooklyn that the Brooklyn Paper listed as being in "poor condition" were: Brownsville branch, 61 Glenmore Ave. at Watkins St. Brooklyn, NY 11212, Carroll Gardens branch, 396 Clinton St. @ Union St., Brooklyn, NY 11231, Flatbush branch, 22 Linden Blvd. at Flatbush Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11226, Arlington branch, 203 Arlington Ave. at Warwick St., Brooklyn, NY 11207, Walt Whitman branch, 93 Saint Edwards St. (between Myrtle and Park Avenues), Brooklyn, NY 11205, Saratoga branch, 8 Thomas S. Boyland St. at "Macon St.", Brooklyn, NY 11233, Leonard branch, 81 Devoe St. at Leonard St., Brooklyn, NY 11215, Eastern Parkway branch, 1044 Eastern Pkwy. at Schenectady Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11213, Washington Irving branch, 360 Irving Ave. (at Woodbine St.), Brooklyn, NY 11237.• All of the libraries in all of the boroughs affected:
• Because the current strategy involves underfunding all of the libraries in the New York City system in order to shake loose and prioritize these real estate deals wherever they be, every library is suffering negative consequences as a result.
• The Queens Library sub-system has so far been the most protective of its libraries. Some libraries in Queens lease space rather than being in publicly-owned properties so there is little real estate value to trying to sell off those particular libraries (unless there is s a very long-term, low-rent lease). Still, because the strategy is to underfund all the libraries in the city to shake real estate properties loose from the system, the Queens libraries are also deleteriously affected; the Borough President must divert more discretionary funds in the direction of libraries (making those funds unavailable to the borough for other uses) and those funds are less effective in bringing library services up to an suitable level.• Libraries in The Bronx and Staten Island:
• The Elmhurst public library in Queens, which the Historic Districts Council fought with the community to save, was bulldozed. That property was not sold off to a developer for another use; it only turned into a construction project the appropriateness of which can be investigated. Alternatives would have included added library space to the existing library off or on site.
• According to the New York City Independent Budget Office’s critique of the mayor’s push to drive down funding of the libraries, “The funding fall-off is already taking a toll on the city’s three library systems, particularly the systems in Brooklyn and Queens.” . . .“more than three dozen branch libraries may be closed.”
• Here is a link to the HDC campaign to save libraries, which includes libraries in Queens.
• The Bronx and Staten Island libraries are part of NYPL subsystem whose board of trustees have focused themselves on a prioritized creation of the real estate deals in Manhattan. What we are seeing is that the juiciest real estate deals are getting priority, but what we know from the Brooklyn situation is that they are working their way down a list.CONTACT: To contact Citizens Defending Libraries email Backpack362 (at) aol.com.
• Read the section on the Queens libraries about how the entire system is affected.
• The Historic Districts council is working to save libraries in the Bronx and Staten Island as well as the other boroughs.
Mayor de Blasio: Rescue Our Libraries from Developer DestructionFor more information about the new petition (including all those to whom it is addressed) and to sign it click here (or past the url below in your browser).
We demand that Mayor de Blasio, all responsible elected officials, rescue our libraries from the sales, shrinkage, defunding and elimination of books and librarians undertaken by the prior administration to benefit real estate developers, not the public. Selling irreplaceable public assets at a time of increased use and city wealth is unjust, shortsighted, and harmful to our prosperity. These plans that undermine democracy, decrease opportunity, and escalate economic and political inequality, should be rejected by those we have elected to pursue better, more equitable, policies.
• Mayor Bill de Blasio, MayorIt is always worthwhile directly contacting elected representatives (and candidates for elected office about these issues), particularly those who represent you, whom you now or who are high on the list above.
• The New York City Council,
• Melissa Mark-Viverito, Speaker
• Scott Stringer, NYC Comptroller
• Letitia James, Public Advocate
• Eric Adams, Brooklyn Borough President
• Gale Brewer, Manhattan Borough President
• Melinda Katz, Queens Borough President
• Ruben Diaz Jr., Bronx Borough President
• James S. Oddo, Staten Island Borough President
• Eric Schneiderman, NYS Attorney General
• Jimmy Van Bramer, City Council Culture Committee Chair
• Costa Constantinides, City Council Library Committee Chair
• Brad Lander, City Councilman, Steve Levin, City Councilman
• Corey Johnson, City Councilman
• Daniel R. Garodnick, City Councilman
• Helen Rosenthal, City Council Member
• Daniel Squadron, State Senator
• Velmanette Montgomery, State Senator
• Fred W. Thiele, Jr., State Assembly Library Committee Chair
• Joan Millman, State Assembly Member
• Jim Brennan, State Assembly Member
• Thomas P. DiNapoli, NYS Comptroller
• Trustees of the New York Public Library
• Trustees of the Brooklyn Public Library
• Trustees of the Queens Library
• Liking and following us on Facebook
• Following us on Twitter (@DefendLibraries)Do the same for The Committee To Save The New York Public Library and Library Lovers League.
• Do you support a moratorium on the creation of real estate deals through the selling off of library property until the New York City libraries are all properly funded, which would mean rehiring all-laid off staff, restoration of full library hours, restoration of libraries being open Sunday.
• Do you support a moratorium on the sell-offs of any library real estate (including the sales currently proposed in Brooklyn and the Central Library plan in Manhattan) at very least until such time as those involved in formulation of such deals display a different mind-set, which means community decision-making about what is desired, no shrinkage of the library system and now prioritizing timing (rushing deals through) and benefits for the sake of the real estate industry.
• Do you oppose shrinkage of the New York City’s library systems as is currently being done?
• Will you commit to use the city ULURP process under the city charter (Uniform Land Use Review Procedure) to oppose and prevent any sale of city-owned library sites as part of schemes that shrink the library system (including the sales currently proposed in Brooklyn and the Central Library plan in Manhattan)?
• Do you oppose the libraries' use of private-public partnerships (that become developer-driven and can be readily abused by companies expert in doing so, like Forest City Ratner) when library property is redeveloped?
• Do you oppose destruction and sale of irreplaceable assets, crown jewels of the library system like the research stacks that make the 42 Street library the research library it should be?
• Do you oppose wholesale sell-offs of libraries going on simultaneously?
• Do you oppose rushed and premature closing of libraries as occurred when Donnell was closed in 2008?
• Do you oppose the withholding of vital and core city services like libraries (and schools) as hostages in order to get developments approved?
• Do you support a thorough public review process, including a long lead time and sufficient advance warning when existing libraries are proposed to be decommissioned and replaced?
• Are you calling for investigation and audit of these library system deals?When contacting public officials, do not let anyone tell you that the selling of libraries creates money for the library system. That’s one of the problems: It doesn’t and it can’t- That money typically goes to the city, which has already established the policy of withholding it. That’s what we are determined to change. (Even in the case of certain libraries the NYPL actually owns, sale proceeds can't be counted upon for operations and the city can cut by comparable amounts. Federal and state funds also went toward the original purchase of certain of those libraries.)